Themes
I’ll Give You the Sun: Themes that stood out
Blog post 2
Jealousy and Guilt
When grandma Sweetwine passes, her book of superstitions is given to Jude as they share the same beliefs and theories. We are shown that Jude is obsessed with her grand-mothers superstition bible. Whenever an event occurs, she correlates her suspicions with the experience. Even though Jude’s mother (Dianna) follows the same beliefs, they have a distant relationship. Jude is always competing with Noah for Dianna’s attention and the twins often compare their art pieces with her critics. This creates a lot of jealousy between them.
Due to her mother not showing her enough attention, Jude seeks a lot of validation from her relationships with partners and friends. This drives a wedge between the mother and daughter. Dianna disapproves of her personality traits and tells Jude not to be ‘’that girl’’. When sending the application forms to CSA, Jude didn’t send Noah’s form because I feel that she wanted to seem superior in the eyes of her mother. When their mother passes, Jude begins seeing ghosts of her as well as grandma Sweetwine. I feel that this was her guilty conscience for what she had done to Noah.
Stereotypes
In the novel Noah is referred to as a ‘’broken umbrella’’ by his father, Benjamin who has a conservative personality. Noah, unlike his father, lacks athleticism and strength and is constantly reminded to be a functional umbrella. Benjamin is unaccepting of Noah’s unique personality and he struggles to come to terms with the fact that his son is homosexual. Noah is made to feel guilty about not playing ball, not acting tough enough and allowing Jude to fight his battles against bullies. There is a contrast between how the father feels men are portrayed in society verse how Noah feels. Later in the novel, Noah falls in love with Brian who is an extremely talented gay baseball player. Brian defies the stereotype that professional athletes are all conservative people and he is the perfect combination between Noah and his father.
Blog post 2
Jealousy and Guilt
When grandma Sweetwine passes, her book of superstitions is given to Jude as they share the same beliefs and theories. We are shown that Jude is obsessed with her grand-mothers superstition bible. Whenever an event occurs, she correlates her suspicions with the experience. Even though Jude’s mother (Dianna) follows the same beliefs, they have a distant relationship. Jude is always competing with Noah for Dianna’s attention and the twins often compare their art pieces with her critics. This creates a lot of jealousy between them.
Due to her mother not showing her enough attention, Jude seeks a lot of validation from her relationships with partners and friends. This drives a wedge between the mother and daughter. Dianna disapproves of her personality traits and tells Jude not to be ‘’that girl’’. When sending the application forms to CSA, Jude didn’t send Noah’s form because I feel that she wanted to seem superior in the eyes of her mother. When their mother passes, Jude begins seeing ghosts of her as well as grandma Sweetwine. I feel that this was her guilty conscience for what she had done to Noah.
Stereotypes
In the novel Noah is referred to as a ‘’broken umbrella’’ by his father, Benjamin who has a conservative personality. Noah, unlike his father, lacks athleticism and strength and is constantly reminded to be a functional umbrella. Benjamin is unaccepting of Noah’s unique personality and he struggles to come to terms with the fact that his son is homosexual. Noah is made to feel guilty about not playing ball, not acting tough enough and allowing Jude to fight his battles against bullies. There is a contrast between how the father feels men are portrayed in society verse how Noah feels. Later in the novel, Noah falls in love with Brian who is an extremely talented gay baseball player. Brian defies the stereotype that professional athletes are all conservative people and he is the perfect combination between Noah and his father.
Comments
Post a Comment